Blog

    5 million reasons to support effective charters, close failing ones.

    Texas public schools educate 5 million students.

    Texas doesn’t need more charters. It needs more high-performing charter schools. Acting swiftly to close failing charter schools protects Texas students and families while creating more opportunities for high-performing charter schools to serve students.

    Why Can’t TEA Close Failing Charter Schools?

    It takes too long to revoke a charter for poor performance, putting students and taxpayers at risk. TEA does not act to revoke a charter until after four years of Academically Unacceptable performance. Because a charter is considered to be a property right, charter revocations typically take 2-3 additional years, during which time students are left in a poor performing school. In one case, TEA has been working to revoke a charter for 12 years!

    TEA lacks the authority to suspend charter operations for imminent insolvency before a school term begins. If a charter runs out of funds during the academic year, it puts students and families at risk of disruption, displacement and loss of academic progress.

    TEA lacks clear standards for charter renewal. As a result, poorly-run charter schools are often allowed to continue to operate despite chronic performance problems.

    TEA lacks the authority to address poor governance by charter schools. TEA does not have the authority to reconstitute a charter school board that is failing to carry out its obligations, or to address nepotism or conflicts of interest

    According to the Texas Sunset Advisory Commission:

    • The percentage of charter school campuses rated Academically Unacceptable was nearly twice that of traditional public schools (11.2% vs. 5.9%).
    • Charter schools educate 3% of the student population in Texas, but account for 25% of the TEA’s workload.
    • The percentage of charter school operators failing state financial accountability standards in 2012 was more than six times that of public school districts (13.1% vs. 2%).
    • Charter school campuses represent 71% of the campuses with sanctions but only 17% of total public school campuses.
    • Out of a total of 482 charter school campuses for 2010-2011, 54 were rated Academically Unacceptable. According to the Sunset Commission, many charters have been rated Academically Unacceptable for multiple, non-consecutive years, with 53 charters rated Academically Unacceptable for 3 or more years and one charter campus rated Academically Unacceptable for a total of 7 years.

    TAKE ACTION

    Here’s what the Texas legislature can do to keep public schools strong:


    • Strengthen charter schools and charter school enforcement by adopting key recommendations of Texas Sunset Advisory Commission staff:
      • Require the Commissioner to revoke charters for failure to meet fiscal or accountability standards for three years in a row;
      • Give the Commissioner authority to suspend operations and revoke charter if the school is about to become insolvent;
      • Strengthen the charter renewal process so that Commissioner has clear authority to not renew a charter for accountability, fiscal, governance or other failure to comply with terms of charter; and
      • Strengthen charter schools governance by authorizing the Commissioner to reconstitute charter boards, applying nepotism and conflict of interest standards.
    • Issue a five-year provisional license to new charter applicants so that those that fail to perform adequately can be shut down without lengthy lawsuits.
    • Maintain existing TEA standards that allow high-performing charters to open new campuses without obtaining a new charter (referred to as “replication”).
    • Oppose significant expansion of the current cap on the number of charters until significant progress is made in revoking poor performing charters.

    Download Issue Brief

    NextPrevious
    • Texas Public School Choice Spinner

      Texas public schools are dynamic and diverse, and they continue to add new options and innovative programs to meet the needs and passions of Texas students, the future of our state.

      Read More

    • We polled Texans about education—they responded loud and clear

      The Governor, Lt. Gov., and House Speaker recently held a joint press conference and announced that this legislative session would be the session of education funding and higher teacher pay. A public opinion poll we commissioned says the public is aligned with those overarching priorities, and that Texans have strong opinions about the specifics of how legislators should proceed.

      Read More

    • Session Toolkit

      We created this Session Toolkit to provide up-to-date information about what is happening at the Capitol and resources that can be used to support issues like increased funding for public schools and early childhood education. Our hope is that it can serve as a “one-stop-shop” for social media graphics, research, videos, and more. Bookmark this page and visit it often!

      Read More

    • Meet the Charles Butt Scholars

      The Charles Butt Scholarship for Aspiring Teachers recipients are not only impressive students, but they are also inspiring individuals

      Read More

    • New Story: From Migrant Farmer to Future Teacher

      If you go by statistics, Raquel Perez wasn’t supposed to be a success story. She wasn’t supposed to be an educational inspiration. Raquel is a migrant farmworker from one of the poorest regions in the country. She never experienced a complete school year in one state.

      Read More

    • Dear Texas Commission on School Finance

      Raise Your Hand Texas appreciates the work of the Texas Commission on School Finance. We recently sent a letter to members of the commission expressing our gratitude and outlining our considerations prior to the final adoption of their recommendations next week.

      Read More

    • Letter to the Texas Commission on School Finance

      Raise Your Hand Texas appreciates the work of the Texas Commission on School Finance. We recently sent a letter to members of the commission expressing our gratitude and outlining our considerations prior to the final adoption of their recommendations next week.

      Read More

    • VIDEO: This is Where the Future Begins

      Anyone who recently has set foot in a public school knows incredible and important work is unfolding under increasingly challenging circumstances. And inside the school walls, teachers and school leaders know that this is where the future begins.

      Read More